Re: (TFT) LOR

["Quite Confused" <Confused3141@hotmail.com>]

Thanks for the info.

> They had to drop some events from the book for time sake and Arwen (Liv
> Tyler), Aragorn's babe has a larger role.

Of the three best book to film adaptations I've ever seen, two have been
animations. Both of these left scenes out from necessary time restraints,
neither ever added significance to any aspect of the original story. The
huevos it takes to say that I could make Tolkin better..... no sense. Not
implying that someone couldn't do a great re-telling of Tolkin, maybe even
better but for goodness sake call it something else. Don't hang the LOR
title on it if you "improved" it simply to get people to come see it.



> Jay states,
>
> Quite true. But the Moria seens were great! I dug the battle at Helms Deep
> too. I wonder if the new flick is gonna butcher the plot as badly as
Bakshi?
> I saw some pics that had Aragorn dressed all in black with a black bow. I
> don't remember that, does anyone else?>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>
> You need to check out theonering.net I believe they are doing a good job.
> They had to drop some events from the book for time sake and Arwen (Liv
> Tyler), Aragorn's babe has a larger role.  I believe Peter Jackson is
doing
> an admirable job directing.  But we all must remember this is Hollywood,
> which is trying to draw an audience.
>
> Yours on the Middle Earth side of Cidri,
> Justin
>
>
=====
Post to the entire list by writing to tft@brainiac.com.
Unsubscribe by mailing to majordomo@brainiac.com with the message body
"unsubscribe tft"