[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: (TFT) Melee tournament Champion of Champions FINAL ROUND
Okay, lets look at this spearman vs Short sword straight up without any c
harges average damage for Spear is 4 [(1d+2)-1 for small shield]: average
damage for short is 6 (2D-1). So in a straight battle the sword will wi
n most of the time (75+%).
Next scenario if you allow the two hex thrust or the spearman takes the
free attack when the swordsman comes in from outside 5 hexes and has no a
ttack. Rd1 Spear 4 dam, sword 0; Rd 2 spear 4 dam, sword 6; Rd 3 sword 6
, spear dead because of -2 DX penalty. So in 1000 battles (Again I don't
have a simulator, but I am sure someone does) I would expect sword to wi
n at least 55% or better.
So the only place spear is better is with a charge, now I will argue tha
t he shouldn't get one even 50% of the time. Here is why; on the melee bo
ard the characters start 13 hexes apart with a first turn initiative roll
So if the sword wins initiative and makes the spear go first; then spear
has to stay either in the 4 entry hexes or 3 megahexes farthest from swo
rds entry hex or he will be engaged next turn and lose the battle. Turn
2 starts sword 6 hexes or so from spear then initiative is determined if
sword wins he has spear move and then engages, there will be no possible
charge. Thus if sword wins initiative he should win the battle. You mig
ht be saying wait what if spear went up against the wall so he only had f
ront hexes to attack, in that case sword stops one hex away (this allows
a two hex jab if using those rules). However a charge is not possible no
matter the initiative outcome on the next round, either sword closes the
one hex or spear runs and sword catches him and they are engaged the next
turn. In both cases sword should win.
Next option again it is turn 2 with sword 6 hexes or so from spear who w
ins initiative. Spear has sword to go first, sword has two options depend
ing on deployment he can either run around to spears side or rear hexes o
r stay where he is. If he runs around spear is not engaged so he can ope
n and get to a 50% initiative roll on the next turn. However is sword st
ays put spear still can't get a charge his best option is to close to cha
rge distance and hope to win initiative again otherwise it is stalemate.
it makes no sense for spear to move first as he will end up engaged if yo
u were thinking there was another option
Reboot scenario 2: If spear wins initiative at the start of the game and
then makes sword go first, the best he can hope for is a 50% chance to w
in initiative next round by getting within 5 hexes. Obviously if spear w
ins initiative the next turn he will charge. If sword goes to the center
megahex or any of the six surrounding megahexes he can reach anywhere on
the board. That means that if he wins initiative on the following turn h
e can either avoid the charge and engage or if he can't close without acc
epting charge damage he can open the range.
Thus you can see by playing the position game the spearman will not get
a charge 100% of the time and probably less than 50% which dramatically d
rops his survival rate.
Finally if he does get his charge 50% of the time and lands it 84% and g
ets a knockdown 72% that means that spear devastating attack only happens
30% of the time (in the only chance he has) vs 16% for the swordsman in
multiple rounds. Also if Spear is 1+1 then that drops to 24%. So even i
f spear wins 90+% of those battles he is still right around 50/50 with sw
ord and if you use 24% spear loses more than 50% of the battles.
7100 Stevenson Blvd Suite 105
Fremont, CA 94538
Office Phone 510-646-1500
Mobile Phone 510-579-0135
------ Original Message ------
Received: 01:31 AM PDT, 10/19/2015
From: Robert Ward <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Subject: Re: (TFT) Melee tournament Champion of Champions FINAL ROUND
I hadn't done this in a while and got out the map to try. I agree sw
can avoid a charge but only if spear makes a bad mistake.
I think the only way spear does *not* get a charge is if spear mov
first and makes a mistake by ending movement with a 6 or 7 hex
separation from sword. Sword moving second can then move 9 or 10 h
to engage spear from the side/rear. Neither gets an attack that tu
but next turn spear is engaged and no charge attack is possible.
Separation of 1-5 hexes:
spear wins initiative: moves first and charges
sword wins initiative: sword moves first to outside of charge
range; spear moves second to keep 1-5 separation.
Separation of 6-10 hexes:
spear wins initiative: makes sword go first. Spear then moves to
a 1-5 distance if possible or if not maintains 8-10 distance.
sword wins initiative: Makes spear go first. Spear maintains
On Mon, Oct 19, 2015, at 06:31 AM, Edward Kroeten wrote:
> Something is rotten in Denmark, a spearman against a short sword
> nd small shield should end up being more often a dead spearman.
> e the spearman gets the charge attack 50% of the time, but a sav
> al short swordsman can reduce that well below 50%.
> On the Melee board the short swordsman should never start a turn
> ithin 5 hexes if he can avoid it. If the swordsman wins initiati
> he is outside 5 hexes he has a 0% chance of being charged and an
> t chance of being engaged on the following turn. He may have to
> ne round of non charge damage, this is acceptable as his weapon
> ior damage and he stops on hit with his shield
> Or if he loses initiative then the spearman most likely will mak
> him move first. With a little planning he can make sure he ends
up at le
> ast 5 hexes away (not getting trapped in a corner), thus still a
> harging damage. If the spearman moves first and ends up less tha
n 10 hex
> es away run up against a side hex so as not to accept the 2X dam
> that is not possible start the process over.
> The only time a spearman can land charge damage is he wins the i
> tiative within 5 hexes, which should be well less than 33% of an
y round p
> Outside of charging the average damage done by a spearman will b
> 4 [(1D+2)-1 for small shield)] which will not cause a -2 shift t
o DX (onl
> y a 33% chance of a -2DX). As where a Short Sword is 6 which wil
> the -2 (58% of the time). Also outside of double or triple damag
e the sp
> earman has a 0% chance of a knockdown as where the sword has an
> e. This means that in an even exchange in one round that the fol
> round ends with swordsman at DX 13 and spear at 11 and an 83% ch
ance of h
> itting which should kill the spearman before his chance to reply
> I think somewhere in the simulation that there was not enough da
> ing by the non spearmen. Staying away from them and then closing
. The o
> nly advantage the spearman has is the charge which the risk of c
an and sh
> ould be avoided as much as possible.
Post to the entire list by writing to email@example.com.
Unsubscribe by mailing to firstname.lastname@example.org with the message
This e-mail message and any documents accompanying this transmission may co
ntain confidential information and are intended solely for the addressee (s)
named above. If you are not the intended addressee/recipient, any use of, d
isclosure, copying, distribution, or reliance on the contents of this e-mail
information is strictly prohibited. Please reply to the sender advising of
the error in transmission and immediately delete/destroy the message and any
Farmers Group, Inc. and its subsidiaries and affiliates, including Farmers
Financial Solutions, LLC, reserve the right to monitor and review the conten
t of all e-mail communications and attachments sent or received by or from t
his address and to retain them in accordance with the applicable regulatory
requirements. Securities are offered through Farmers Financial Solutions, LL
C, 30801 Agoura Road, Building 1, Agoura Hills, California 91301. Member FIN
RA & SIPC.
Post to the entire list by writing to email@example.com.
Unsubscribe by mailing to firstname.lastname@example.org with the message body